GoodRx Care vs PeterMD
GoodRx Care scores higher overall (8.1 vs 6.3).
By Julian Caraulani · prices checked
Quick verdict
Our pick between the two: GoodRx Care
GoodRx Care scores 8.1/10 against 6.3 for PeterMD, ahead on price, clinical care and reputation. PeterMD can still be the better fit: it is best for men paying with an FSA or HSA who want FDA-approved generics.
Side by side
| GoodRx Care | PeterMD | |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest price | $16/mo (depends on delivery cadence) | Not published |
| Our score | 8.1/10 | 6.3/10 |
| Treatments | Erectile dysfunction (ED), Hair loss | Erectile dysfunction (ED), Hair loss, Men's lab tests, Low testosterone (TRT and enclomiphene) |
| Medication in price | Included | Included |
| Drugs dispensed | FDA-approved | FDA-approved |
| Labs | Not stated | Optional: Quest panels from $247 |
| Membership | None required, per GoodRx's launch release | None found |
| Insurance | No (GoodRx Care Direct is not insurance) | No; FSA and HSA accepted |
| States | 48 states (not ND, SC), per its own site (2026-10-31) | 48 states (not AL, ID), per its own site (2026-10-31) |
| Cancellation | Cancel any time from the GoodRx dashboard | Auto-renews; cancel by email at least 48 hours before renewal; no refunds once medication is received |
| FDA warning letters | None found (October 31, 2026) | None found (October 31, 2026) |
| Trustpilot | 3.8/5 (4,071 reviews) | No profile we could quote |
| Best for | Men who want FDA-approved generics only from a large, familiar brand. | Men paying with an FSA or HSA who want FDA-approved generics. |
| Prices checked | 2026-10-31 | 2026-10-31 |
Price by treatment
The lowest all-in plan each publishes for the treatments both offer, with the page we read it on.
| Treatment | GoodRx Care | PeterMD |
|---|---|---|
| Erectile dysfunction (ED) | $18/mo (monthly, or a 3- or 6-month supply upfront) source, 2026-10-31 | No all-in price published |
| Hair loss | $16/mo (depends on delivery cadence) source, 2026-10-31 | No all-in price published |
GoodRx Care: a closer look
GoodRx's own ED and hair loss subscriptions with FDA-approved generics, from $16 to $18 a month. We searched the FDA warning-letter database on October 31, 2026 and found no letter naming GoodRx Care.
In its favour
- FDA-approved generics only
- Consult and delivery in one monthly price
- Cancel any time from the dashboard
To weigh
- Prices are 'from' figures in press material, not a full price list
- Trustpilot score covers all of GoodRx, mostly coupons
- FTC order in 2023 over sharing health data for ads
PeterMD: a closer look
FDA-approved generic sildenafil from $6 a tablet and finasteride from $45 a month; FSA and HSA accepted. We searched the FDA warning-letter database on October 31, 2026 and found no letter naming PeterMD.
In its favour
- FDA-approved generics only
- FSA and HSA accepted
- Pack prices published
To weigh
- Consult fee unclear, so no all-in monthly price
- Per-tablet prices are high next to other programs
- Trustpilot no longer shows its profile
Which should you choose?
Choose GoodRx Care
Best for men who want FDA-approved generics only from a large, familiar brand. Its lowest all-in plan is $16/mo (depends on delivery cadence).
Check GoodRx Care's priceChoose PeterMD
Best for men paying with an FSA or HSA who want FDA-approved generics.
Check PeterMD's priceGoodRx Care vs PeterMD: questions people ask
Which is better, GoodRx Care or PeterMD?
On our published score GoodRx Care rates 8.1 and PeterMD rates 6.3. GoodRx Care is best for men who want FDA-approved generics only from a large, familiar brand; PeterMD is best for men paying with an FSA or HSA who want FDA-approved generics.
Do GoodRx Care and PeterMD offer the same treatments?
GoodRx Care: Erectile dysfunction (ED), Hair loss. PeterMD: Erectile dysfunction (ED), Hair loss, Men's lab tests, Low testosterone (TRT and enclomiphene).
Does either include the medication in the price?
GoodRx Care: included. PeterMD: included.
Men's Health Watchdog is for information only and is not medical advice. Sildenafil, tadalafil, finasteride, oral minoxidil and testosterone are prescription drugs (testosterone is a federally controlled substance); talk to a licensed clinician about whether one is right for you and at what dose. Partner links may earn us a commission; our score never depends on it. Compare other programs.